THE Tanzanian football landscape is currently captivated by a brewing rivalry, not just between the traditional giants Young Africans (Yanga) and Simba SC, but also between their respective midfield linchpins: Moussa Balla Conte and Yusuph Kagoma.

Young Africans’ recent capture of 21-year-old Guinean sensation Conte (pictured) from CS Sfaxien, a move that reportedly thwarted Simba's own pursuit, has intensified the debate. 

While both players are earmarked as crucial to their clubs' ambitions, their performances in the demanding 2024/25 CAF Confederation Cup offer a unique lens through which to compare their contributions and potential.

Kagoma has been a cornerstone for Simba SC, a tireless worker and versatile presence in midfield, instrumental in their impressive journey to the CAF Confederation Cup final. His experience in a high-performing squad gives him a considerable edge in immediate impact. 

In contrast, Moussa Balla Conte, despite his clear talent and potential, operated within a struggling CS Sfaxien side that finished at the bottom of Group A. 

This disparity in team success makes a direct, statistically balanced comparison challenging, but it highlights the different environments in which they showcased their abilities.

Statistical snapshot from the 

2024/25 CAF Confederation Cup

A deeper dive into their continental campaign statistics reveals distinct playing styles and contributions:

Appearance & Playing Time:  Kagoma demonstrated greater consistency and durability, featuring in 10 matches for Simba, accumulating 779 minutes on the pitch. This translates to an average of roughly 78 minutes per game, underscoring his integral role throughout Simba's extended run. 

Conte, on the other hand, participated in seven matches for CS Sfaxien, logging 591 minutes. While his average of 84 minutes per game suggests he was a key figure when on the pitch, his team's early exit meant fewer opportunities to influence outcomes over a longer period.

Offensive Contribution: Neither player registered a goal during the competition, indicating their primary roles are not as direct goal-scorers. However, Kagoma edged Conte in terms of final third involvement by recording one assist across his 10 appearances. 

Conte, conversely, did not provide any assists, reinforcing the perception of a more defensively oriented role.

Shooting & Attacking Play: Kagoma exhibited a slightly more forward-thinking approach, attempting three shots with one on target. This suggests a willingness to join attacks and test the opposition goalkeeper, albeit in a limited capacity. 

Conte, in line with his deeper midfield role, registered 0 shots throughout his campaign, further solidifying his profile as a player focused on shielding the backline rather than direct offensive threats.

Defensive Discipline & Influence: Kagoma’s high engagement in midfield battles is evident from the four fouls he committed and the 16 fouls he suffered. This indicates his active involvement in disrupting opposition play and drawing fouls. 

However, his disciplinary record is a significant concern. He received a costly red card in the 50th minute of the second leg of the final against RS Berkane, a moment that arguably shifted the momentum and contributed to Simba's defeat. 

He also picked up another yellow card in a group-stage match, highlighting a tendency for bookings under pressure. 

Conte, while precise foul data is not detailed, received two yellow cards during his campaign. His caution frequency suggests active defensive involvement, but without the high-stakes disciplinary lapses seen from Kagoma.

Playing Roles & Style:Conte is primarily recognized as a defensive midfielder, adept at shielding the backline, breaking up play, and controlling the midfield tempo. His lack of shots and direct goal contributions aligns with this anchoring role. 

Kagoma, in contrast, toggles between defensive and central midfield roles, showcasing a slightly more box-to-box presence. His solitary assist and attempts on goal indicate a more versatile player capable of contributing to both defensive solidity and occasional creative sparks.

Impact and Outcomes: Kagoma's prominence in Simba SC's successful run to the final, despite his disciplinary setbacks, underscores his significant impact within a high-performing team. 

His consistent selection and occasional attacking involvement give him a slight edge in overall contribution. 

Conte, while delivering steady minutes as a disciplined holding midfielder, was unfortunately part of a CS Sfaxien side that struggled to make an impact, which inevitably limited his opportunities to showcase his influence in winning situations. 

While specific metrics like tackles and interceptions for Conte would offer a more comprehensive comparison of defensive solidity, the team outcomes undeniably favor Kagoma.

Implications for Their Clubs and The Future

Young Africans' acquisition of Conte signals their intent to gain a balanced defensive pivot that can bring structure and tactical discipline to their midfield, essential for controlling the game's tempo. His youth, at 21, suggests a higher ceiling and considerable potential for development, making him an exciting long-term investment for Young Africans.

Simba, on the other hand, continues to benefit from Kagoma’s versatility and endurance. His contributions in both defensive solidity and occasional creativity support their fluid midfield transitions. 

However, for Kagoma to maximize his impact in crucial matches, he must address his disciplinary issues and cultivate better composure under pressure.

The debate among fans of Young Africans and Simba SC ultimately boils down to a classic dilemma: potential versus proven performance. Young Africans supporters will likely view Conte as a future star who could eventually surpass Kagoma. Simba loyalists, however, can confidently point to Kagoma’s integral role in their team's deep continental run, arguing that his experience and consistent work rate currently make him the superior player, despite his disciplinary lapses.

Based on their performances in the 2024/25 CAF Confederation Cup, Kagoma holds a statistical and experiential advantage due to Simba’s superior team performance and his prominent, albeit sometimes flawed, role in their journey to the final. 

Conte, while demonstrating promise, was hampered by CS Sfaxien’s poor campaign, making it more challenging to fully assess his individual impact in a struggling unit.

As Moussa Balla Conte embarks on his new chapter with Young Africans, his development within a highly competitive Tanzanian environment will be keenly watched. 

The upcoming 2025/26 season promises to be a crucial proving ground, where Conte will have the opportunity to directly challenge Kagoma’s established dominance in Tanzanian football. 

The unfolding of this midfield rivalry on the pitch is undoubtedly a narrative that fans will follow with eager anticipation.